Introduction
As an asset owner or manager, looking for ways to increase production for your wind farm, you may be wondering about options such as “blade furniture”, and if so, you likely have questions about the efficacy of the various options and whether it might make sense for your wind farm.
To maximize returns for operational windfarms, requires focusing on all of the small gains possible that can add up to significant energy output increases and revenue growth over time.
One of the most promising innovations in turbine optimisation is "blade furniture" — a set of aerodynamic modifications designed to enhance wind turbine performance. Blade furniture offers an opportunity to increase production for existing turbines, with improvements in energy production, noise reduction, and overall turbine efficiency.
In this post, we’ll explore what blade furniture is, how it works, and what are the performance improvements the providers claim their solution can deliver for wind farm owners.
Whether your turbines are under warranty or outside warranty, this article will provide valuable insights on the options available.
Later, we will provide our summary of the various methods.
What Is Blade Furniture?
Blade furniture refers to a range of physical modifications or add-ons applied to wind turbine blades to improve their aerodynamic performance. These enhancements can include components such as:
Vortex Generators:
Small fins or entrainers installed on the blade’s suction side.
They create mini vortices in the airflow, delaying separation and allowing more energy capture from the wind.
Additional benefit: noise reduction due to smoother airflow.
Chord Extensions:
Extensions added to the trailing edge of the blade to increase its lift and energy-capturing capacity.
Commonly used to boost performance by around 1.5%.
Winglets:
Small extensions added to the blade tips.
They reduce drag and improve overall efficiency, often contributing up to 4% in energy yield increases.
Blade furniture is designed to augment the existing blade structure without requiring major overhauls, making it a popular choice for operators seeking incremental but impactful upgrades.
How Blade Furniture Increases Performance
The underlying goal of blade furniture is to improve the interaction between turbine blades and the wind. Here’s how each type of blade furniture contributes to enhanced performance:
Improved Aerodynamics:
Vortex Generators: By delaying the separation of airflow from the blade, these devices maximize the energy extracted from the wind while minimizing turbulence.
Chord Extensions: These improve the blade’s surface area and lift, enabling the turbine to generate more power at the same wind speed.
Enhanced Control:
Technologies like winglets help stabilize airflow at the blade tips, reducing inefficiencies caused by turbulence. This stabilization can improve the turbine’s overall performance and reduce wear and tear on components.
Noise Reduction:
Smoother airflow means less aerodynamic noise, a key consideration for turbines located near residential or sensitive areas.
Cost-Effective Output Gains:
With potential performance improvements ranging from 1.5% to 4%, blade furniture can yield significant additional energy over time without the expense of replacing entire blades or turbines.
Other options available for improving turbine performance
If you’re not a fan of blade furniture, there are several other upgrade options that can deliver meaningful performance improvements.
Software Upgrades:
These upgrades typically promise performance improvements ranging from 0.1% to 8%.
Key features include better wind speed estimation, improved yaw tracking, and pitch tuning.
Uprating:
Uprates involve increasing the rated output of the turbine based on site load assessments and grid export limits.
This approach can have the most significant impact on performance gains.
Other Minor Improvements:
Smaller optimizations, such as adjustments to cut-in speeds and dynamic tuning, also contribute to incremental gains.
These options are often implemented as part of broader performance improvement packages, leveraging the latest advancements from the original equipment manufacturer (OEM). The application of these improvements depends on which are of the power curve you wish to target, as outlined below.
Key Considerations Before Implementing Blade Furniture
While blade furniture offers compelling benefits, there are several factors to evaluate before implementation:
Design Compatibility:
Blade furniture must align with the specific design and model of the turbine.
Operators should assess whether they need custom or generic solutions.
Material Durability:
High-quality materials and adhesives are essential to ensure reliability under extreme wind and weather conditions.
Poor-quality installations can fail, leading to performance degradation or costly repairs.
Planning and Regulatory Requirements:
In some jurisdictions, modifications like chord extensions or winglets may require updated permits due to visual or operational changes.
Cost-Benefit Analysis:
Analyse the expected energy gains against the installation and maintenance costs.
For example, winglets may deliver higher gains but require more upfront investment compared to vortex generators.
Real-World Results and Success Stories
Blade furniture has delivered measurable results in operational settings. For example:
Vortex Generators:
Projects using vortex generators have reported up to 3% increases in energy yield, particularly in turbines operating in turbulent wind conditions.
Chord Extensions:
In one case, chord extensions installed on a fleet of turbines led to a 1.5% improvement in output, recovering installation costs within two years.
Winglets:
Operators implementing winglets on older turbines have seen up to 4% performance gains, breathing new life into aging assets.
These examples highlight how small, strategic upgrades can significantly enhance long-term returns for operators.
Beyond Blade Furniture: Complementary Upgrades
To maximize turbine performance, blade furniture can be combined with other upgrades and improvements:
Control System Optimization:
Earlier cut-in speeds: Adjustments that allow turbines to generate power at lower wind speeds.
Enhanced yaw positioning: Reduces inefficiencies caused by misalignment with wind direction.
Rotor Speed Adjustments:
Various proprietary OEM technologies optimize rotor speed based on real-time conditions, adding another layer of efficiency.
Late Cut-Out Upgrades:
Reducing high wind hysteresis allows turbines to continue generating energy during higher wind speeds, albeit with safety controls.
SCADA System Analysis:
Advanced data analysis can identify underperformance due to yaw misalignment, pitch inaccuracies, or other issues.
Summary
To provide a concise overview of the various performance enhancement options for wind turbines, we've compiled the following summary table. This table outlines each option, its potential benefits, and additional comments to assist in decision-making.
Option | Stated Benefit | Comment |
Vortex Generators | 1-3% energy yield improvement | Reduces turbulence and improves airflow. |
Chord Extensions | ~1.5% performance boost | Increases lift by extending blade surface. |
Winglets | Up to 4% energy yield increase | Reduces drag; most effective on older turbines. |
Software Upgrades | 0.1% to 8% performance improvement | Includes better wind speed, yaw, and pitch tuning. |
Uprates | Significant gains, subject to grid limits | Increases rated power output of the turbine. |
Optimized Rotor Speed | Incremental energy gains | Adjusts rotor speed for real-time wind conditions. |
Late Cut-Out | 0.1-0.5% gain | Extends operation in high wind speeds. |
Yaw Positioning | ~0.2-0.3% improvement | Corrects alignment errors for peak performance. |
Power Curve & Underperformance analysis | Varies considerably. Undetected, under performance can go for long periods. | Significant losses can accumulate over time, so it might be worth having detailed analysis performed periodically or if you observe production decline in any turbines |
Conclusion
Blade furniture represents a cost-effective, high-impact solution for wind turbine operators looking to boost performance and revenue. With technologies like vortex generators, chord extensions, and winglets, operators can extract more energy from their existing turbines while reducing noise and wear.
However, these upgrades require careful planning and validation to ensure compatibility, durability, and regulatory compliance. By combining blade furniture with complementary upgrades and data-driven insights, operators can achieve even greater efficiency and maximize their return on investment.
If you’re interested in exploring how blade furniture or other upgrades can benefit your wind farm, contact EnergyPro today for a tailored performance assessment.
Comments